'Such a course would be injurious to the service' - General's letter is for sale


2015-06-26 12:15:27


'Such a course would be injurious to the service' - General's letter is for sale

The renowned Confederate General Robert E Lee is set to star in Heritage's auction of Americana

Next week, bidding will open in Heritage's rare manuscripts auction, based on Americana, specifically Texana.

One of the star lots is a letter signed by Confederate a career military officer who is best known for having commanded the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia in the American Civil War. Lee remains admired, despite his lot falling on the wrong side of history.

The letter is a brisk, negative reply to John Bailor. John R Baylor was a passionate Texan who, before the Civil War, was known as a vigorous Indian fighter and a member of the Knights of the Golden Circle.

Authorised to create a mounted brigade of Texans to retake the Arizona Territory Baylor, still in Richmond, wrote to General Lee, who had recently been promoted to general-in-chief of all Confederated forces, with a plan to exchange non-Texans for the famed Texas Brigade under Lee's command.

Robert E Lee ManuscriptRobert E Lee Manuscript

"Sir,"Your letter of the 14th inst. is received. I cannot recommend the plan you propose for replacing the Texas troops in this army. It would break up organized commands in the West, and give us an unorganized body of men here of little value.

"I think such a course would be injurious to the service. If two or three good regiments could be sent over, it would be better in every respect. If there be in the regiments selected old men, or others unfit for the duties of service here, they might be put on detached duty in Texas, or transferred to some regiments that will remain in that Department.

"In this way, the exchange might be made without injury, but to take men from their present commands for the purpose of sending them here, would in my opinion, reduce our strength in the Trans-Mississippi Department, and add but little to it here."

The letter does not yet have an estimate associated with it, but Lee autographs and memorabilia can be very valuable and a good investment. For example, three letters written by Lee during the Civil War sold at auction for $61,000. Indeed the record for a Lee item is $630,000.

Heritage's auction takes place in Dallas and online on March 12.

Recent and Related Articles...

RAF officer's 1924 Iraq medal offers a piece of the past for four figures | 3 February 2011

One of only 11 Military Medals awarded to RAF officers between WWI and WWII is up for sale

The Story of... The rare Russian Order of St Andrew the First-Called | 26 January 2011

We take a look at the award, an example of which sold for the equivalent of $2.1m in 2010

Gold and platinum Order of Lenin leads the way at Cumbrian medals auction | 24 January 2011

Another opportunity to track the pace of the Russian medals market arises in the UK

Order of St George Russian gold coin could bring $134,000 at Kuenker | 17 January 2011

It was created to mark the anniversary of Russia's first military medal, St George's Order of Merit

Rare Russian medal set brings $117,000 in 'outstanding' New York auction | 16 January 2011

The sale by Baldwin's, Dmitry Martov and M&M Numismatics set the tone for 2011 in coins and medals

Image: Heritage

Share on social media
Write a response...

The bookmarklet lets you save things you find to your collections.

Note: Make sure your bookmarks are visible.


Click and drag the Collect It button to your browser's Bookmark Bar.